Showing posts with label Kaitlyn Finley. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kaitlyn Finley. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 07, 2019

OCPA column: Hospitals raised prices after Medicaid expansion


Hospitals raised prices after Medicaid expansion
By Kaitlyn Finley

A new study shows that a key claim made by Medicaid expansion advocates is likely false.

Part of the sales pitch for Obamacare’s Medicaid expansion, which is being pushed in Oklahoma in the legislature and with a ballot measure, is that it will reduce medical bills. The argument goes like this: when hospitals treat some people for free, they have to charge everyone else more. This is called “cost shifting.” Expanding Medicaid means hospitals will have to offer less charity care, and should be able to reduce prices.

Yet many Colorado hospitals increased prices despite receiving more reimbursement payments from taxpayers after Medicaid expansion, according to a state report.

The analysis from the Colorado Department of Health Care Policy and Financing found that hospitals’ margins per adjusted patient discharge for all payer types, including Medicare, Medicaid, and the privately insured, more than doubled from $538 to $1,359 from 2009 to 2017. The state report reveals that hospitals spent their increasingly subsidized revenues on building more hospitals, particularly in metropolitan areas, on buying out physician practices, and on further consolidating hospital systems.

The report finds that these new expansion projects were focused in areas that did not need more medical facilities. “New construction seems to correspond to the regions that do not need new facilities nor new hospitals, with new hospital construction concentrated largely in the higher income areas of Colorado, such as Longmont/Boulder.” The construction was focused on these lucrative areas and largely ignored lower-income areas.

According to the report, “Hospitals could have passed on significant savings to commercial consumers had they matched national cost benchmarks using Medicare Cost Reports[,] suggesting as much as 8.3 percent in cost savings or $7.9 billion from 2009 to 2017.”

In response to these findings, Kim Bimestefer, executive director of the Colorado Department of Health Care Policy and Financing, told Kaiser Health News, “Hospitals had a fork in the road to either use the money coming in to lower the cost-shift to employers and consumers or use the money to fuel a health care arms race. With few exceptions, they chose the latter.”

Colorado’s experience shows why throwing billions of taxpayer dollars at a broken and opaque health care system by expanding Medicaid will not serve to improve health care—or lower costs—in Oklahoma.

Kaitlyn Finley is a policy research fellow at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs.

Monday, March 18, 2019

OCPA column: SB605 is bad policy, no matter where you try it


Senate Bill 605 is bad policy, no matter where you try it
By Kaitlyn Finley, policy research fellow at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs.

Although Oklahomans have wisely rejected repeated attempts to expand Medicaid under Obamacare, new proposals keeping popping up in their place like the many-headed Hydra.

The latest expansion proposal at the Oklahoma Capitol, Senate Bill 605, claims to be a “conservative” alternative to traditional Medicaid expansion. But SB 605 is just Obamacare Medicaid expansion by another name.

SB 605 would expand medical welfare benefits to a potential 628,000 able-bodied, working-age adults in Oklahoma. The program would be designed under the authority of a federal waiver. These new welfare beneficiaries would receive Medicaid benefits through commercial plans administered by another state-run program, Insure Oklahoma. If implemented, the federal government would pick up 90 percent of costs accrued from new expansion enrollees while Oklahoma state taxpayers would pay for the remaining 10 percent of costs. Based on the number of eligible enrollees and average per-person costs, Oklahoma state taxpayers could be on the hook for $374 million annually if they implemented SB 605.

Despite real-world fiscal nightmares in other states, some expansion proponents still claim that expanding Medicaid through a waiver and utilizing private commercial health plans will be a cheaper way to expand Medicaid. These are unfounded claims. Look no further than Arkansas, Iowa, and New Hampshire. These states implemented a plan similar to the one proposed in SB 605 and it left them in a financial mess.

Arkansas’ “private option” expansion plan has accrued more than $1.4 billion in cost overruns in the past three years. Iowa and New Hampshire decided to scrap their alternative expansion plans altogether in 2015 and 2018, respectively. To make matters worse, these states’ “conservative” expansion plans turned out to be even more expensive than if they had just adopted traditional Medicaid expansion in the first place.

Oklahoma lawmakers should be wary of any “conservative” option, like SB 605, to expand Medicaid through a federal waiver. Putting aside the price tag, any supposedly conservative features may be rescinded by the next liberal president, leaving Oklahoma paying the tab for all the costs from a new entitlement class of hundreds of thousands of able-bodied, working-age adults.

Oklahoma has already seen this happen when the Obama administration threatened to gut Insure Oklahoma and push individuals onto the expensive Obamacare exchange. The Obama administration did not want to approve an extension for Insure Oklahoma because the program has enrollment caps in place and generally requires beneficiaries to be working in order to receive partially subsidized health insurance. Oklahoma’s recent history with the Obama administration shows how foolish it would be to rely on temporary waivers, where authority lies solely with the federal government, particularly for proposals that have shown to be an inefficient use of taxpayer dollars.

With all the financial nightmares and program chaos surrounding waivers for Medicaid expansion and the rapid rise in Medicaid enrollment in general, states like Oklahoma should be wary of any expansion proposal. This is especially true when the whole plan relies on a temporary waiver and on promises of reimbursements from a benefactor that is already $22 trillion dollars in debt.


Kaitlyn Finley serves as a policy research fellow focusing on health care and welfare policy for the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs.

Tuesday, January 29, 2019

OCPA column: short-term health insurance brings more choice, savings


More choices, more savings: Short-term health insurance
By Kaitlyn Finley, policy research fellow at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs

Faced with ever-rising health insurance premiums, more Americans are searching for alternatives that won’t break their budget.

Thanks to regulatory action by the Trump administration last August, people in certain states may now take full advantage of a more affordable category of health insurance—short-term, limited-duration medical insurance (also called short-term insurance).

Unlike traditional health insurance plans, these flexible short-term plans are not subject to restrictive Obamacare regulations under federal law. As a result, short-term plans’ premiums can be up to 70 to 80 percent cheaper than certain silver and bronze plans on Obamacare Exchanges.

In addition to cost-savings, consumers may enroll in these plans any time during the year, which may help those who missed the Obamacare enrollment deadline. A recent survey of 1,000 short-term insurance beneficiaries by eHealth found that 51 percent of people would have been uninsured if they did not have access to short-term plans. Overall, recipients of these plans are generally satisfied with their coverage under these plans. eHealth’s survey found 78 percent of people who accessed medical services stated they were happy with the coverage under their short-term plan.

Under current federal regulation, these plans can offer initial coverage for up to 364 days and may be renewable for up to 36 months. In an effort to force more people to purchase Obamacare plans, the Obama administration limited their coverage to three months without the option to renew. The three-month coverage period hindered people who needed flexible health insurance coverage for interim periods, for possibly up to four to twelve months.  For instance, individuals that were still job searching or waiting for open enrollment after their initial three-month period ended were left uninsured with no options.

Although the Trump administration greatly reduced federal regulations for this category of insurance, many states still impose stronger restrictions on short-term plans. For example, state regulations in Maryland, Oregon, and Hawaii limit coverage to 90 days. As of January 1 this year, California has prohibited the sale of short-term plans entirely. Currently, Oklahoma law limits short-term plans to six months with no option to renew.

States should not ban these plans or arbitrarily suppress coverage duration. Consumers should have the ability to review all options and choose the best available insurance plan that fits their coverage needs on their schedule.

Kaitlyn Finley serves as a policy research fellow focusing on health care and welfare policy for the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs.